BTRC issues show-cause notice to Robi over ‘Cirkle’ brand
The Bangladesh Telecommunication Regulatory Commission (BTRC) has issued a show-cause notice to mobile operator Robi Axiata over its use of the new brand name ‘Cirkle’, following objections from nationwide internet service provider Circle Network.
The regulator has asked Robi to explain within seven days why it should not be directed to stop operating under the ‘Cirkle’ brand.
According to documents obtained by AI News BD, the notice was issued by the BTRC's legal division on 26 October and addressed to Robi's chairman, managing director and chief executive officer. It was signed by commission deputy director Md Maidul Islam. The notice was subsequently reissued, replacing the earlier version under the same date and reference number. Copies were sent to the office of the BTRC chairman and Mahbub Alam, proprietor of Circle Network.
The notice raises two main issues.
First, the BTRC referred to the terms of the 2016 merger between Robi and Airtel, under which the company was required to operate under the name Robi Axiata Limited. On 23 July 2023, the Posts and Telecommunications Division also directed that Airtel could no longer be considered a separate licensed operator following the merger, but rather a brand of Robi.
The commission said advertisements promoting the ‘Cirkle’ brand were identifying Airtel as an operator, raising questions about compliance with the merger conditions.
Second, the BTRC noted that Circle Network, a licensed internet service provider, has been operating nationwide under the name ‘Circle’ since 2016. The commission questioned whether Robi's use of the similar name without prior approval could conflict with intellectual property laws.
The notice followed an application submitted by Circle Network to the BTRC chairman on 8 September.
In its application, the company said it had received a nationwide ISP licence on 1 March 2016 and had since been providing internet services under the name Circle Network. The name has been used in licence renewals, correspondence with the commission, tariff approvals and promotional activities, it said.
Circle Network argued that the names ‘Circle’ and ‘Cirkle’ are similar in spelling, pronunciation and appearance. Both are written and pronounced ‘সার্কেল’ in Bangla. As the two companies operate in the telecommunications and internet services sectors, the similarity could create confusion among customers, it said.
The company fears consumers may mistakenly believe the two businesses have a commercial relationship or partnership, potentially damaging Circle Network's established reputation and goodwill.
It further argued that using different logos and English spellings would not eliminate confusion because both brands have the same Bangla identity.
Circle Network clarified that it was not challenging Robi's legitimate right to operate its telecommunications business. Its objection, it said, was primarily aimed at protecting its long-established brand identity and preventing consumer confusion.
The company requested regulatory and legal action to prevent the use of ‘Cirkle’ or ‘সার্কেল’ as a brand name and submitted copies of its licence and trademark documents with the application.
Robi launched ‘Cirkle’ as a replacement for Airtel at an event in Dhaka on 17 August.
At the time, the company described the move as a brand evolution rather than an operational change. Airtel customers were automatically transferred to the new brand without any changes to their 016 numbers, packages or account balances.
Robi said the new brand was aimed at young consumers and would introduce technology-driven digital services, including artificial intelligence-based offerings.
Leave A Comment